Can Carlos Beltran make the Hall of Fame?

The Super Bowl is all done. That means the vans are packed and that pitchers and catchers are heading towards Spring Training. I for one am very excited.

There are quite a few players in the MLB getting long in the tooth. We know that this year will be highlighted by the David Ortiz Farewell Tour. Many will argue that Big Papi is Hall of Fame bound, while others will tell you that if Edgar Martinez isn’t in the Hall of Fame, than neither should Ortiz.

Well, what about some of those other possible retirees? What about Carlos Beltran?

You would have to imagine that this is Beltran’s last season. He will be 39 a few weeks after Opening Day and he hasn’t played a healthy season in two years. He had a solid second half last season when he was healthy, but even the promising numbers he put up were not typical Beltran numbers.

That’s because Beltran will go down as one of the greatest switch hitters in the history of the game, but those days are long gone. I have him in my top five all time, but many will argue that Tim Raines — whom I have at six — should be in there. What’s that? Who are my Top Five?


  1. Mickey Mantle
  2. Chipper Jones
  3. Pete Rose
  4. Eddie Murray
  5. Carlos Beltran

So, shouldn’t a top five player in a major aspect of the game be instantly considered Hall of Fame bound? The Mick and Murray are Hall of Famers, Rose would be if he weren’t an idiot, and if Chipper isn’t a first ballot Hall of Famer I’ll be very disappointed.

Take a look at Beltran’s career numbers and they are fringe Cooperstownian at best:

  • .280/.355/.490 slash line
  • 1,449 runs, 392 home runs, 1,444 RBI
  • 311 stolen bases in 360 attempts for an 86% career success rate and that, folks, is insane

So he is in the top 80 in baseball history in every stat aside from the slash line. You can assume that even if Beltran plays only 100 games this season, he will surpass the 400 home mark, the 2,500 hit plateau, and jump above 1,500 runs and RBI. He is also the eighth member of the 300/300 Club, joining names like Willie Mays, Bobby and Barry Bonds and Andre Dawson. Again, sounds like Hall of Fame credentials when you throw them all together, doesn’t it?

That means we need to check in with the SABR department to see what the stat geeks would say. I have said it before, and I will say it again. Until their can be one common equation amongst all of the SABR sites to determine a universal WAR, I will take it with a grain of salt. I will use it as a comparison tool, but not much more than that. Let’s compare Beltran to a few Hall of Famers and possible Hall of Famers that had similar paths in their careers (all WAR numbers taken from FanGraphs).

  • Hall of Famer Jim Rice: 50.8 WAR
  • Hall of Famer and fellow 300/300 Club member Andre Dawson: 59.5 WAR
  • Hall of Famer Tony Perez: 58.9 WAR
  • Should-be Hall of Famer Tim Raines: 66.4 WAR
  • Beltran: 66 WAR

Now, myself, I really like to look at wRC+ and wOBA to determine a player’s value. wRC+ or weighted runs created (100 is around league average) shows a player’s offensive value in terms of runs. wOBA or weighted on-base average can determine a player’s worth per plate appearance. Let’s compare the same players, shall we?

  • Rice: 128 wRC+; .375 wOBA
  • Dawson: 117 wRC+; .350 wOBA
  • Perez: 121 wRC+; .356 wOBA
  • Raines: 125 wRC+; .361 wOBA
  • Beltran: 120 wRC+; .362 wOBA

(side note: one of my favorite players of all time that gets not even a notion of Hall of Fame love is Jim Edmonds. His WAR is 64.5, his wRC+ is 127, and his wOBA is .385 ten points higher than anyone on the above list. If metrics were the true, sole judge of a player’s greatness, then shouldn’t Edmonds have at least been considered? How absurd does that sound?)

The advanced metrics make it tough, and also bring Rice, Dawson and Perez’s Hall of Fame residency into question when Rock isn’t in there. Beltran is right there, and if baseball is truly a sport of tradition, his metrics deem him a Hall of Famer, no?

Beltran has a Rookie of the Year Award, but his trophy cabinet is not overflowing with accolades. He has three gold gloves and two silver sluggers, but does that a Hall of Famer make? The one thing Beltran really wants is a World Series ring.

His postseason stats are out of this world. A .332/.441/.674 slash line with 16 home runs, 40 RBI and a perfect 11-for-11 in stolen bases over 52 games. Those 16 home runs are No. 9 ALL TIME in the postseason and six of the people ahead of him have at least 100 more at bats, while the other two have 40 more at bats.

The question you ask yourself, when you sit down and you look at Carlos Beltran, do you really think he is a Hall of Famer? Personally, he isn’t someone I tab as Cooperstown bound.

But as they say, numbers don’t lie. He has matched — and could still surpass this season — many of his contemporaries who set the benchmark (grant it the far end of the bench) for Hall of Fame induction. Should Beltran hang it up at the end of this season, he will certainly stir up some debate in five years.

3 thoughts on “Can Carlos Beltran make the Hall of Fame?”

  1. You do not mention but doesn’t Beltran have the highest postseason OPS of all time – he passed Ruth a few years back……even if Wainwright got him…


    (was Rice’s wOBA park-adjusted?)

    1. You know it’s funny. You are correct that I did not mention it in the article, which I should have, but just yesterday a Mets fan on a fan site was trolling me talking about how terrible a post-season hitter Beltran was because of one infamous at bat. Of course then I whipped out the OPS number as you brought up.

      In regard’s to your question on Rice’s wOBA being park adjusted, I’m not so sure if you are asking about Rice specifically or not, so I will give a general answer. Batting average/ OBP are simply a number assuming that all hits/walks are equal, when in actuality we know they are not. wOBA has given a specific value to each way of reaching base and FanGraphs has come up with an equation to show how valuable a player is to the lineup in regards to how they get on base.

      I would assume you are asking about Rice perhaps in regards to playing with a short porch or the Green Monster throughout his career. In short, I don’t believe that comes into play.

      Thanks for reading.

      1. Actually, I’m a Mets fan myself – and i hate he died with the bat on his shoulder, not even swinging, but the pitcher turned out to be pretty good in the long run himself. Just trying to be fair to Beltran

        Rice career OPS – home, .920, road, .789. 131 points difference! Pulled a few examples of other differentials…
        Ruth – 33.
        Aaron, 15
        Mays – 22
        Mantle – 39

        Then two chosen specially for this – Fenway folk
        Williams – 71
        Yaz – 125 (similiar)

        and the classic, 300+ HR home, <200 away,
        Ott – 62

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.